paratti: (Marlena by Theda Bara)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] paratti at 11:20pm on 19/03/2008 under
I really liked it. It upped the pace nicely after last week's pause of creepiness after the angst of the Owen Death Arc. We got a tight Gwen pov episode to balance out the tight Owen pov of his. We got Gwen and Tosh teaming up to solve the case while Jack and Ianto went 'Weevil hunting'. We got Ianto slipping Gwen a clue to the location she needed to go to next after the girls had worked out what was happening to the missing. We got Ianto and Jack getting hot and heavy amid Owen's plants - and Jack up for a threesome.

We got a show of both Gwen caring and a friend that loves her calling her on when she slipped into doesn't. We got a reason why Andy wasn't at the wedding and it be a good character point. We got the Aw Bless reunion and the Oh Fuck! some things can't be fixed and some people would be better off with just hope over the knowledge of horror. We got Jack called on his shit and the way he behaves - both openly by Gwen and on the down-low by Ianto. We got the two natural seconds in command that are Jack and Gwen compete for alpha status. And above all, we got a story whose plot device was so wonderfully sensible - of course a rift that drops off things and people will also take them. There's more story in stuff and beings that get dropped off but basic physics tells us that for each action there is an equal and opposite reaction, so of course it will take people and some of them will find their way back, and because there's not only wonders out there but horrors to be faced and fought there will inevitably be casualties too - especially unprepared civilians without a tame-ish Time Lord or Time Agent to run with.

I'm sure some of the Gwen haters will hate the fact that PC Andy - who was quite unbelievably cute and adorable and pretty in this - does love her, but I don't. It adds a lovely extra line of story for them, the Andy snark at Rhys - who was also adorable in this - and the Rhys snark at Andy felt real and human rather than the side effect of Sue- ishness, which the show avoided by having all three of them be shown as very human and fallible and by having each of them calling each other of their shit, rather than boosting one at the expense of the other two which is an epitome of Sue Horror. It also let the show explore why Gwen's doing what she is as well as whether the mother would be happier retconned, which she can't be without doing the damaged son who probably shouldn't have more meddling done to his mind.

I like that the rift can take people to terrible places, like the solar system burning. Wonders if that was Ark in Space solar flares or the Earth frying tonight. I, as a crossover fiend, love that Team Cardiff have given us a crossover device par excellence in the form of a rift that can go anywhere and anywhen. As a lover of consequences I love that using it can have costs to the unlucky and the uniformed.

And I love Gwen with Rhys - they argue so well and support and love each other so much. And I love Andy and that he does love his friend and that's why he wouldn't go to the wedding. Got to love someone who knows better than and values themselves enough to put themselves through that. And Andy wants to join Torchwood. YES PLEASE. And Gwen doesn't want - presumably not only for his own sake but to avoid, presumably, a repeat of the Owen situation.

Speaking of Owen, he didn't have much to do - but he has had huge amounts recently, so that was fair.

Did anyone else think of Sea Devils - WANTS Sea Devils on either show soon, please - or Fang Rock when they were on the island?

I'm sure some people won't like the position Jack takes in this one re the missing and the return, but they did do a good job in showing why he took the position he did from the situation he inherited and given that they can't retrieve them until they turn up again.

And we get another episode on Friday:) For which this one oomped up the pace nicely, after the necessary breather that was PJ Hammond's Sapphire and Steel script.

X Posted to IJ
There are 13 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
usedtobeljs: (Five Mad Dogs & Time Lords by Magpie)
posted by [personal profile] usedtobeljs at 12:05am on 20/03/2008
Hurrah for your show continuing to please you. :-)
 
posted by [identity profile] paratti.livejournal.com at 12:13am on 20/03/2008
Thanks:) It was good:)

((hugs))
 
posted by [identity profile] marvola.livejournal.com at 12:28am on 20/03/2008
We got the two natural seconds in command that are Jack and Gwen compete for alpha status.

Oh, dear God! This one sentence was like a ray of sunshine appearing from behind a dark cloud! (Or something not quite so melodramatic!) You're absolutely, 100% right! Gwen works best under Jack (mind out of the gutter!) and Jack worked best under the Doctor! The only natural leader on the whole team is probably Ianto. Well not yet, but he's the one with the most potential to be leader in the future. Bloody hell. This has actually changed how I view the dynamic of the show!
 
posted by [identity profile] paratti.livejournal.com at 12:35am on 20/03/2008
Happy to be of help:)

It was really telling how happy and relaxed Jack was when he was back with the Doctor and how he he when he has to be the one giving orders and making decisions. Gwen's much the same - though I think she shades it in the natural leader stakes.
 
posted by [identity profile] marvola.livejournal.com at 01:58am on 20/03/2008
It really was. I've heard people complain because Jack-in-TW is so different to Jack-in-DW but this really makes sense and explains the difference in characterisation. And as one of life's second in commands myself, I really should have recognised this sooner.
 
posted by [identity profile] paratti.livejournal.com at 08:26am on 20/03/2008
It really makes sense. He's trying to be the Doctor and the leader and is working against the grain to do so. That's stressful.
 
posted by [identity profile] chloris67.livejournal.com at 08:15pm on 21/03/2008
That *is* a great observation! This changes my view of the dynamic too! And helps reduce my annoyance with Jack, because he's really been driving me nuts lately.
 
posted by [identity profile] redeem147.livejournal.com at 05:16am on 20/03/2008
I think this was the best we've seen of Chibnall.

Last week, I wasn't paying attention during the credits, but a few minutes in I thought "I'll bet this is the Sapphire and Steele guy".
 
posted by [identity profile] paratti.livejournal.com at 08:33am on 20/03/2008
Which bodes well for the last two episodes, which he wrote too.

It did have a definite feel of a S&S idea/ep, didn't it.
 
posted by [identity profile] curiouswombat.livejournal.com at 11:54am on 20/03/2008
Sorry - this is almost a non-sequitor - except that I read 'Fang Rock' as Fraggle Rock. And you have a rift that will allow crossovers in all directions....
 
posted by [identity profile] paratti.livejournal.com at 02:00pm on 20/03/2008
A Fraggle Rock/Fang Rock crossover could be fun - in a really high death count sort of way;)
 
posted by [identity profile] harmonyfb.livejournal.com at 03:27pm on 06/04/2008
The things that I came away from this episode with were:

1. Worst Mother EVAH. Why is she more concerned with her own dashed hopes than her son's suffering? If it were MY son, I'd have already moved onto the damned island, brought all his things, and be working on ways to help make him better (even a little relief would be better than none.)

2. Gwen is a crap-ass do-gooder. This was about her feeling bad about herself, not about helping others. Otherwise, she'd have gone to ALL of those people and helped them relocate their loved ones. And they're all idiots if they can't make up enough of a cover story to return those folks to their families.

3. Jack/Ianto=hotness. Jack/Ianto/Gwen=potential lava-hotness. Rhys/Gwen/Andy=even hotter.
 
posted by [identity profile] paratti.livejournal.com at 12:41pm on 07/04/2008
Same here. Even if its just wielding a paint brush while he screams, as even I can't do anything about that I could do something for the others. And its not as if Retconning her would help Jonah, as he'd need Retconning too to forget that she came once and never again and further messing with a mind that damaged would probably do even more damage.

I do wonder if some of them aren't radiation contaminated and it wouldn't be possible. That place had re-used bunker all over it. But yep, Ianto needs to fake some more deaths.

Word.

May

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31